> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.theutahplum.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Amendment A, explained
- URL: https://www.theutahplum.org/amendment-a-explained/
- Published: 2026-10-14T11:56:49.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T23:35:30.000Z
- Description: Utah’s least controversial amendment this cycle.
- Author: Nick Huey
- Tags: Elections, #Migrated-1794257016514, #Import 2026-11-09 13:44

Your ballot is on its way, winding through the United States Postal Service toward your mailbox. Which means you and I are about to make some big decisions about Utah’s future by filling in some very small ovals. As with any test, studying is recommended, and this article is our best attempt at a nonpartisan study guide.

Before we walk through Amendment A, I want to invite anyone who hasn’t yet to take a look at our analysis of [the more controversial Amendment B](https://www.theutahplum.org/p/amendment-b-explained). We included a rebuttal from Billy Hesterman, the president of the Utah Taxpayers Association, and it’s a doozy.

*DISCLAIMER: In this article I tell you where I land in the end. If you’d rather decide on your own first, stop reading at “My take.”*

###### *Reading time: about 9 minutes* 
*Research & writing: about 7 human hours*

## What is Amendment A?

Here is the question as it appears on [your ballot](https://www.utah.gov/pmn/files/1484353.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org):

*“Shall the Utah Constitution be amended to change how proposed constitutional amendments are published, requiring publication for 60 days immediately before the general election in a manner established by state law instead of in newspapers?”*

Before Utahns can vote on a proposed change to the state constitution, the Legislature must publish the full text in advance. It’s a requirement that has been a part of Utah’s constitution since it was written in 1895: “in at least one newspaper in every county of the state, where a newspaper is published, for two months immediately preceding the next general election.”

[Amendment A](https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HJR010.html?ref=theutahplum.org) deletes the newspaper part. Instead, it requires that [proposed amendments be published](https://le.utah.gov/xcode/ArticleXXIII/Article%5FXXIII,%5FSection%5F1.html?ref=theutahplum.org) “in a manner provided by statute, for 60 calendar days immediately preceding the next general election.”

In plain English, the constitution would still require the Legislature to publish every proposed amendment for 60 days prior to ballot voting. However, where it gets published would be decided by ordinary state law, which the Legislature can change with a regular bill.

Lawmakers already wrote the law deciding where amendments need to be published. [HB481](https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0481.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org) tells the lieutenant governor to publish the full text of every proposed amendment on the [Utah Public Notice Website](https://www.utah.gov/pmn/?ref=theutahplum.org) and on the lieutenant governor’s own website for 60 days before the election. Newspapers are no longer required.

If Amendment A passes, it takes effect [Jan. 1, 2027](https://le.utah.gov/~2025/bills/static/HJR010.html?ref=theutahplum.org).

If you want to share an even-handed, educational article on Amendment A, this is it.

### Back up. Why is this on my ballot?

In 2023, the Legislature passed [SB43](https://le.utah.gov/~2023/bills/static/SB0043.html?ref=theutahplum.org), a bipartisan cleanup bill that changed the [publication requirements for constitutional amendments](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-supreme-court/116649026.html?ref=theutahplum.org), replacing newspaper notices with notices on government websites. But the constitution itself wasn’t changed. It still contained the two-month newspaper requirement.

In 2024, the Legislature put four amendments on the ballot, and Lt. Gov. Deidre Henderson followed the new law and [posted them online](https://ltgovernor.utah.gov/carousel/public-notice-full-text-of-proposed-constitutional-amendments/?ref=theutahplum.org). Nobody bought newspaper space because they thought they didn’t have to anymore.

The League of Women Voters of Utah and Mormon Women for Ethical Government [sued](https://www.axios.com/local/salt-lake-city/2024/09/12/utah-amendment-d-ballot-initiatives-gerrymandering-ruling?ref=theutahplum.org) over Amendment D, the measure that would have let lawmakers rewrite citizen initiatives at will. They made two arguments: The ballot language was misleading, and the text was never published in newspapers as required by Utah’s constitution.

Once the lawsuit was filed, the Legislature [bought ad space in 35 newspapers](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-supreme-court/116649026.html?ref=theutahplum.org) for the week of Sept. 16, 2024, but it was too late. The election was less than 60 days away.

Third District Judge Dianna Gibson [voided Amendment D](https://www.axios.com/local/salt-lake-city/2024/09/12/utah-amendment-d-ballot-initiatives-gerrymandering-ruling?ref=theutahplum.org) on Sept. 12, 2024, on both grounds. On Oct. 9, Third District [Judge Laura Scott voided](https://www.ksl.com/article/51151842/district-judge-issues-permanent-injunction-voiding-utahs-amendment-a-regarding-school-funding?ref=theutahplum.org) 2024’s Amendment A. Both amendments were already printed on the ballot, but the votes were never counted.

In its [full opinion](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-supreme-court/116649026.html?ref=theutahplum.org) on the matter, the Utah Supreme Court wrote that one week of ads “fifty days before the election does not satisfy the requirement that the amendment be published ‘for two months.’” It also left the door open: “The Legislature may have a point that the newspaper publication requirement is outdated, but it cannot rewrite the constitution by statute. Nor can this court rewrite it by opinion.”

Amendment A is the Legislature’s answer.

### Which lawmakers voted for Amendment A?

All of them. Rep. Anthony Loubet, R-Kearns, sponsored it, and Sen. Dan McCay, R-Riverton, carried it in the Senate. The House [passed it 70-0](https://ballotpedia.org/Utah%5FPublication%5FRequirements%5Ffor%5FConstitutional%5FAmendments%5FMeasure%5F%282026%29?ref=theutahplum.org) with every Democrat and Republican present voting yes. The Senate passed it 29-0\. Nobody spoke against it in [the House committee](https://le.utah.gov/interim/2025/html/00001755.htm?ref=theutahplum.org) hearing. In [the Senate committee](https://le.utah.gov/interim/2025/html/00001966.htm?ref=theutahplum.org), the only public comment came from [Alliance for a Better Utah](https://betterutah.org/?ref=theutahplum.org), which said it was neutral. And because no lawmaker voted against it, the state’s [voter information pamphlet](https://vote.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-Voter-Information-Pamphlet.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org) has no argument against Amendment A.

### Why the lack of opposition?

Amendment A has its critics, but nothing like Amendment B. That’s likely because Amendment A won’t just make it easier for the Legislature to pass amendments. It will also make it easier for citizens to pass initiatives.

The Legislature passed [SB73](https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0073.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org) last year. Starting in 2027, it requires the sponsors of statewide citizen initiatives to publish them “in the same manner required for a constitutional amendment.” Sponsors could end up spending [$1.4 million or more to put their initiative in newspapers](https://utahnewsdispatch.com/?p=8238&ref=theutahplum.org) for two months, just like the Legislature has to do every time lawmakers want to pass a constitutional amendment.

If Amendment A passes, initiative sponsors could publish online for free, the same way the state does.

Today, we’ll share views from supporters and critics of Amendment A. Then, Editor-in-Chief Nick Huey’s take.

## What supporters of Amendment A are saying

- **Nobody reads legal notices in the back of the paper anymore. Put the full text where people actually get their information.**
- **The newspaper rule costs up to $1.4 million every election. The state can reach more people online for less.**
- **The constitution should set the principle, which is notice, and let the law set the method.**

#### Rep. Anthony Loubet, the amendment’s sponsor, [to the Deseret News](https://www.deseret.com/politics/2026/10/06/two-amendments-one-fights-utah-ballot-november/?ref=theutahplum.org), on why the rule made sense in 1895:

> “Back in the day, that was a great way of communicating with people. People received their newspapers daily and that would be (a) good method of notification. Unfortunately nowadays that’s not true any longer.”

#### Rep. Anthony Loubet and Sen. Dan McCay, the sponsors, in their official argument in the state’s [2026 voter information pamphlet:](https://vote.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-Voter-Information-Pamphlet.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org)

> “The Utah Constitution currently requires public notices about constitutional amendments and statewide initiatives to be published in print newspapers in all 29 counties. While that made sense when newspapers were the primary source of information, most Utahns now rely on digital sources, mobile devices, and online platforms to stay informed.  
>  
> “Amendment A updates Utah’s public notice requirements to reflect how people access information today while preserving transparency and public awareness. Utah taxpayers currently spend approximately $800,000 to publish these notices in newspapers statewide. Despite that expense, print notices are increasingly unlikely to reach the broad audience they once did. Amendment A allows Utah to use modern publication methods that can better connect voters with important election information while reducing unnecessary costs.  
>  
> “Public notice is only effective if people can easily find and review it. Amendment A ensures information about proposed constitutional amendments remains widely available while allowing state law to use communication methods that reflect how Utahns receive information today. Amendment A does not eliminate public notice. It updates how public notice is delivered. By modernizing an outdated constitutional requirement, Utah can maintain transparency, improve accessibility, and save taxpayer dollars.”

#### The Legislature’s attorneys, in their 2024 brief to the Utah Supreme Court, [as quoted in the Court’s opinion](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-supreme-court/116649026.html?ref=theutahplum.org):

> “The Utah Constitution enshrines principles, not application of those principles.”

## What critics of Amendment A are saying

- **The Legislature broke this rule in 2024 and is now asking voters to erase it.**
- **A future Legislature could change where and how the notice appears with a simple bill, no vote of the people required.**
- **A newspaper is an independent record somebody else keeps, and it still reaches people who aren’t online.**

#### The Network of Utah Moderates, a group of Utahns who say many of their members come from traditionally conservative backgrounds, [in a post urging a no vote](https://networkofutahmoderates.com/p/a-closer-look-at-amendment-a?ref=theutahplum.org) on Oct. 12:

> “While this change from newspaper to online seems acceptable right now, we’re nervous that if the way to advertise for amendments can be changed after the amendment passes, Utah’s legislative branch could theoretically impose relatively easy rules for itself and more difficult ones for citizen-led initiatives. We’ve seen double standards happen before (again, see Amendment B).”

#### Katharine Biele, president of the League of Women Voters of Utah, in an email to The Plum:

> “Amendment A only addresses what they do not need to do to ensure citizen knowledge and participation and it does not address what needs to be done. It should not be changed until they have the bills in place for how they will increase knowledge and participation.”

#### The Utah Supreme Court, in its [unanimous opinion](https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/ut-supreme-court/116649026.html?ref=theutahplum.org), on why the rule exists:

> “The drafters of our constitution and the people who ratified it determined that the appropriate way to ensure that voters understood a proposed amendment was continuous publication of its full text in at least one newspaper in each county for two months prior to the election. They also deemed it necessary to enshrine that precise method in the constitution.  
>  
> “The submission and publication requirements are not mere boxes to be checked before votes can be tallied; they are constitutional safeguards designed to ensure that voters have the information and time necessary to cast an informed vote on a matter as weighty as a constitutional amendment.”

#### Rep. Merrill Nelson, R-Grantsville, [on the House floor in 2019](https://www.deseret.com/2019/2/5/20665102/utah-house-rejects-legal-notice-requirement-bill-amid-worry-it-would-hurt-local-newspapers?ref=theutahplum.org), the last time the House voted down a bill to pull legal notices out of newspapers:

> “This is an unnecessary provision that appears to do more harm than good, especially to the small rural communities who are affected by and really live by their local newspapers.”

Nelson warned the 2019 bill looked like “a first step in an effort to remove all publication notices.” The House killed it, 35-39\. Four years later, SB43 moved most of those notices online anyway.

## My take

- **The newspaper rule from 1895 is outdated. There are better ways to give notice to citizens now.**
- **This amendment saves Utah up to $1.4 million every election cycle.**
- **Future abuse by the Legislature is possible but unlikely to succeed.**

A change in the newspaper rule is long overdue. The updated publication requirement [saves Utah money](https://vote.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/2026-Voter-Information-Pamphlet.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org), and fixes the biggest drawback of [SB73](https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/SB0073.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org), which was going to force citizen initiatives to pay $1.4 million or more just to be counted on the ballot.

The most persuasive argument *against* Amendment A is that it lets the Legislature write its own rules for where it must publish each amendment before an election. In the case of a cartoonishly corrupt Legislature (which I don’t believe we have), that technically means they could change the rules to publish the amendment as a PDF 10 clicks deep on a legislative subpage where no one could find it.

I don’t think we have to worry about that, for three reasons.

- “Published” still has to mean published. When the Legislature tried to swap “newspaper” for a website by statute in 2023, the Utah Supreme Court said “no way.” The Court would be just as unlikely to let the Legislature redefine “published” as a hidden PDF no one can read.
- If the Legislature wanted to move published amendments off the established public notice site, they would have to do so with a public bill, which would immediately trigger a lawsuit from organizations like the [League of Women Voters](https://www.axios.com/local/salt-lake-city/2024/09/12/utah-amendment-d-ballot-initiatives-gerrymandering-ruling?ref=theutahplum.org).
- The constitution still requires [60 days’ notice](https://le.utah.gov/constitutionalAmendment/2026/constitutionalamendments.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org) and publishing the amendment itself, which the Court has read to mean the full text. So attempts to deceptively summarize text or shorten notice periods would run headlong into the constitution.

There are some valid reasons not to like this amendment. But in my mind, the theoretical downsides can be addressed if abuse ever occurs. They don’t justify forcing the Legislature and citizens to pay up to $1.4 million every election for newspaper notices almost nobody reads.

#### What would change my mind:

- If the Legislature starts trimming [HB481](https://le.utah.gov/Session/2025/bills/enrolled/HB0481.pdf?ref=theutahplum.org) and the courts don’t stop them. My whole argument depends on the notice staying easy to find: the full text, on the state’s main public notice site, for all 60 days. If a future bill moves it somewhere obscure or swaps the full text for a summary, and the courts don’t stop lawmakers, I’d be plumb wrong.
- If Utahns actually read the legal notices. I’m assuming almost nobody finds the text of an amendment in the back of a newspaper. If there’s evidence that a real share of voters (say, 10%), especially in rural counties, do, then the newspaper rule is doing more than I’m giving it credit for.

Think we got this one wrong? We want to hear about it.  
The sharpest reader responses may end up in a future article.

[Email us](mailto:contact@theplum.org)